Hebrew | Francais

Search


> > Archive

Shabbat Parashat Lech Lecha 5776

P'ninat Mishpat: An Agent who Gave the Document to the Wrong Person

(based on Shut Chatam Sofer, Choshen Mishpat 140)

Case: Reuven sent his agent (Shimon) with a loan contract to receive payment from the borrower (Levi). Reuven told Shimon that if Levi does not pay, Shimon should not hand over the contract to his partner (Yehuda). At the end, Levi did not pay, and Shimon did give the contract to Yehuda. Yehuda did extract full payment from Levi and is refusing to give Reuven half the money because of the claim that Reuven owes him money from other transactions. Can Yehuda keep the money? Must Shimon reimburse Reuven for causing a loss by not following his instructions?

 

Ruling: Some local rabbanim argue that ostensibly Shimon should have to pay Reuven and, because of this, Yehuda will not be able to withhold Reuven’s half due to the damage it will cause Shimon (see Rama, Choshen Mishpat 58:1). Others say that since Shimon made a mistake regarding what to do with a document, we apply the Rama (CM 55:1), based on the Rashba, that when someone returns a loan contract to the creditor after payment, he is exempt from damage payment because it is gerama (indirect damage).               

The Masat Binyamin (85) deals with the discrepancy between the Rashba above and the Rosh (Shut 39:2), who says that if a scribe gave a document to the buyer’s father rather than the buyer, and the father died and the document was lost, the scribe has to compensate the buyer. There we see that one can be obligated even for a minor mistake made with a document. The Masat Binyamin answers that in the Rashba’s case, there is not immediate damage when the creditor gets the document, as he has yet to extract payment. This is different from the Rosh’s case where there is an immediate loss to the buyer, who is now without his contract, and the Rashba would agree that he must pay. Therefore, the Masat Binyamin (see Shach 55:4) ruled that if an agent gave the contract to the borrower before he paid, the agent would have to pay. Thus, the Rashba’s case is the exception to the rule, and in our case, the agent who gave the contract to Yehuda after being warned not to has far more reason to be culpable than the scribe who delivered the contract to the recipient’s reliable father.

While the above analysis fits the Masat Binyamin’s approach, this is actually a difficult opinion. Consider that the gemara (Ketubot 85a) obligates an agent who paid the creditor before taking the loan contract, which seems against the Rashba. The distinction must depend on who gave the document to the wrong person. A marginally related person can be exempt due to gerama, but someone who was given the document as a watchman or an agent and acts against the instructions or the interests of an interested party is considered a mazik (damager). Thereby, he is obligated even though the normal obligations of a watchman do not apply to contracts and the damage is indirect for others. [The Chatam Sofer explains why this category does not apply in the Rashba’s case, but it is too involved to present in this context.]

Therefore, in this case, Shimon would definitely be obligated to Reuven, and, therefore, Yehuda may not use the document as a tool to seize money that he claims Reuven owes him from a different situation. Rather, Yehuda should give Reuven his half of the loan from Levi, and Reuven should swear that he does not owe Yehuda.

Top of page
Print this page
Send to friend


Dedication

Refuah Sheleymah to

Orit bat Miriam

 

Hemdat Yamim

is dedicated

to the memory of:


those who fell in the war

 for our homeland.

 

R’ Eliezer ben R’ Yitzchak z”l

 

Mrs. Sara Wengrowsky

bat R’ Moshe Zev a”h.

who passed away on

10 Tamuz, 5774

 

Rabbi Reuven Aberman

zt”l

Eretz Hemdah's beloved friend

and

Member of Eretz Hemdah's Amutah
who passed away

on 9 Tishrei, 5776


George Weinstein,

Gershon ben Yehudah Mayer,

a lover of the Jewish Nation

Torah and Land. 

 

R'  Meir
 
ben

Yechezkel Shraga Brachfeld

o.b.m

 

R ' Yaakov ben Abraham  & Aisha

and

Chana bat Yaish & Simcha

Sebbag, z"l

 

Hemdat Yamim

is endowed by

Les & Ethel Sutker

of Chicago, Illinois
in loving memory of
Max and Mary Sutker
and

Louis and Lillian Klein, z”l

site by entry.
Eretz Hemdah - Institute for Advanced Jewish Studies, Jerusalem All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy. | Terms of Use.