Hebrew | Francais


> > Archive

Shabbat Parashat Emor 5782

P'ninat Mishpat: Disappointment with Arba Minim Sales Provisions part III

(based on ruling 74082 of the Eretz Hemdah-Gazit Rabbinical Courts)

Case: [We will deal with this case’s two elements of dissatisfaction separately.] The defendants (=def) are, respectively, suppliers of arba minim (def2) and the organizer of a “buyer’s group” (def1) to rent the courtyard of a public building (=buil) for selling arba minim. Pl are two friends who sold at buil¸ who ordered 300 sets of arba minim including 160 “preserved” lulavim, which are common for high-quality sets. They claim to have received only 80 high-quality lulavim, which made it unrealistic to sell expensive sets, causing a loss of 2,000 NIS between them, which they want reduced from the money they owe for the sets, which they took without paying. Def2 says that they were out of additional preserved lulavim but they offered an alternative package consisting of other high-quality species, which pl refused to take. Def2 claims that it is common, in the great confusion of such a market, that wholesalers cannot provide exactly what was ordered and retailers accept the best alternatives and the sides make an accounting after Sukkot. By not accepting alternatives, pl caused losses for themselves and def2 and must pay for what they ordered. The two sides disagree if pl received 40 or 80 lulavim less than ordered.


Ruling: [After discussing complaints about the rented location, we now discuss the matter of merchandise supplied.]

Regarding the factual question of how many lulavim pl received and must pay for, we accept pl’s claims for the following reasons. First, they are defendants in this matter who are saying definitively that they did not become obligated in more of the payment than admitted. In contrast, def2 seek to receive payment and also do not sound as confident that they gave all but 40. We also expect pl to remember better, as they were dealing only with their small orders, as opposed to def2 who sold 40,000 sets to many dozens of retailers. Whether or not it was customary or wise to do so, pl have a right to accept only the merchandise they ordered, and so they are exempt from paying the 16 NIS each that the 80 lulavim cost, for a savings of 1,280 NIS.

Based on the prices discussed in beit din, pl is claiming that the lack of preserved lulavim caused 20 sets to not be sold (11% of full sales). This is not an exaggerated claim, but the burden of proof is still on pl that the shortage of preserved lulavim caused them to sell significantly less to the degree of certainty to obligate for damage in the form of preventing gain. It is also not clear that pl did not have alternatives to have prevented the damage, such as accepting the alternatives or buying the extra lulavim from a different supplier (pl claimed that def2 repeatedly promised they would provide what was ordered). Therefore, according to strict Halacha, we cannot obligate def2 in damages. On the other hand, def2 themselves said that when an order is not delivered as promised, the buyers and sellers work out a compromise. It is also possible to give a reduction to pl on the other elements of the sets that they bought and did not use. The dayanim disagreed whether and how to calculate a small compromise on this point [the details of which are too technical for this forum.]

Top of page
Print this page
Send to friend


We daven for a complete and speedy refuah for:

Nir Rephael ben Rachel Bracha
Yisrael ben Rivka

Arye Yitzchak ben Geula Miriam

Neta bat Malka

Meira bat Esther

Together with all cholei Yisrael

Hemdat Yamim is dedicated

to the memory of:

Those who fell in wars

for our homeland


Rav Shlomo Merzel z”l
Iyar 10, 5771

Reuven & Chaya Leah Aberman z"l
Tishrei 9
,5776 / Tishrei 20, 5782


Mr. Shmuel & Esther Shemesh z"l

Sivan 17 / Av 20


Mr. Moshe Wasserzug z"l

Tishrei 20 ,5781


R' Eliyahu Carmel z"l

Rav Carmel's father

Iyar 8 ,5776


Mrs. Sara Wengrowsky

bat RMoshe Zev a”h.

Tamuz 10 ,5774


Rav Asher & Susan Wasserteil z"l
Kislev 9 / Elul 5780

' Meir ben

Yechezkel Shraga Brachfeld z"l


Mrs. Sara Brachfeld z"l

Tevet 16 ,5780


R 'Yaakov ben Abraham & Aisha


Chana bat Yaish & Simcha

Sebbag, z"l


Rav Yisrael Rozen z"l
Cheshvan 13, 5778


Rav Benzion Grossman z"l
Tamuz 23, 5777


R' Abraham Klein z"l

Iyar 18 ,5779


Mrs. Gita Klein z"l

Av 4


Rav Moshe Zvi (Milton) Polin z"l
Tammuz 19, 5778


R' Yitzchak Zev Tarshansky z"l

Adar 28, 5781


Nina Moinester z"l

Nechama Osna bat Yitzhak Aharon & Doba

Av 30, 5781


Rabbi Dr. Jerry Hochbaum z"l

Adar II 17, 5782


Mrs. Julia Koschitzky z"l

Adar II 18, 5782


Mrs. Leah Meyer z"l

Nisan 27, 5782


Hemdat Yamim
is endowed by
z"l  & Ethel Sutker
of Chicago, Illinois
in loving memory of
Max and Mary Sutker
& Louis and Lillian Klein z”l

site by entry.
Eretz Hemdah - Institute for Advanced Jewish Studies, Jerusalem All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy. | Terms of Use.